Skip to main content

MacDonnell Appraisals

Home Appraisal Questions Answered

Northwest Missouri & Northeast Kansas

We’re here to help provide clarity and confidence in the home appraisal process.

Here are answers to 20 of the most common questions we’re asked.

A real estate appraiser is a trained, licensed professional who determines the fair market value of a property. They do this by researching the local market, physically inspecting the home, and comparing it to similar properties that have recently sold in the area. The result is a detailed written report — called an appraisal — that provides an objective, unbiased opinion of what a
property is worth on the open market.

Appraisers are independent third parties, meaning they have no financial stake in the outcome of the value. Their job is simply to provide an accurate, well-supported opinion of value based on data, market trends, and professional judgment.

At minimum, your appraiser should hold an active state license or certification in the state where
the property is located. Beyond that, look for someone with meaningful experience appraising
properties in your specific area — local market knowledge is just as important as credentials.

A well-qualified appraiser will also be familiar with the property type they’re appraising, whether
that’s a single-family home, a rural property, or an estate. Additional indicators of quality include
membership in professional organizations such as the Appraisal Institute and a track record of
working with reputable lenders and clients in the region.

Both licensed and certified appraisers are qualified to appraise residential properties, but there
are meaningful differences in their training, testing, and scope of work.

● Licensed Appraiser — Qualified to appraise non-complex residential properties up to a
certain value threshold. They have completed required education and passed a state
exam but have fewer hours of supervised experience than a certified appraiser.

● Certified Residential Appraiser — Qualified to appraise all types of one-to-four unit
residential properties with no value limitation. They have completed more rigorous
education, additional experience hours, and a more comprehensive exam.

● Certified General Appraiser — The highest license level, qualified to appraise all
property types including commercial real estate.

For most home appraisals, a Certified Residential Appraiser is the gold standard.

The distinction comes down to the types of properties each is qualified to appraise. A residential
appraiser specializes in one-to-four unit housing — think single-family homes, duplexes, and
small multi-family properties. A general appraiser holds the highest level of certification and is
qualified to appraise all property types, including commercial buildings, industrial properties, and
large multi-family complexes.

For a standard home appraisal, a certified residential appraiser is the appropriate professional.
If your property includes significant commercial elements or acreage with complex use
considerations, a general appraiser may be more appropriate.

This is one of the most commonly misunderstood aspects of the appraisal process. In most
mortgage transactions, the appraiser’s client is the lender — not the homeowner or the buyer.
The lender orders the appraisal to protect their financial interest in the loan, and the appraisal
report is technically their property.

This doesn’t mean the appraisal isn’t useful to you as a homeowner or buyer — it absolutely is.
But it does explain why the appraiser’s primary obligation is to provide an independent,
unbiased opinion of value rather than to advocate for any particular outcome. When you hire an
appraiser directly, outside of a lending transaction, you become the client, and the report
belongs to you.

A fair and unbiased appraiser is one who is truly independent — meaning they have no financial
interest in the outcome of the appraisal and no relationship with any party that could influence
their opinion of value. In lending transactions, this independence is actually required by federal
law through a system called the Appraiser Independence Requirements (AIR).

When seeking an appraiser on your own, look for someone who is state-licensed or certified,
has strong local market experience, and comes recommended through trusted sources like your
lender, real estate attorney, or agent. Be cautious of anyone who asks what value you’re hoping
to achieve before agreeing to take the assignment — a professional appraiser’s opinion should
always follow the data, not the desired outcome.

Not always, but in most traditional mortgage transactions an appraisal is required. Lenders use
the appraisal to confirm that the property’s value supports the loan amount they’re approving.
Without it, they have no independent verification of the collateral securing the loan.

That said, some loan types and situations may qualify for an appraisal waiver or a desktop
appraisal, where no physical inspection is required. These alternatives are becoming more
common thanks to advances in automated valuation technology. However, they are not
guaranteed and depend on the property type, loan program, and lender guidelines. When in
doubt, assume an appraisal will be required and plan accordingly.

In most mortgage transactions, lenders are required to use an independent process to select
appraisers — they cannot simply hand-pick their preferred appraiser. Many lenders work
through an Appraisal Management Company, commonly called an AMC, which acts as an
intermediary between the lender and the appraiser. The AMC assigns appraisal orders to
qualified appraisers in the area based on factors like geographic competency, availability, and
credentials.

This system exists to protect appraiser independence and prevent any undue influence on the
outcome of the appraisal. In some cases — particularly with smaller community banks or credit
unions — lenders may maintain their own approved appraiser panels and select directly from
that list.

When you are actively going through the financing process with a lender, the short answer is no
— the lender is required to select the appraiser independently. This is a federal requirement
designed to protect appraiser independence and ensure there is no outside influence on the
opinion of value.

Outside of the loan process, however, hiring an independent appraiser is not only possible — it
can be a smart strategic move. If you are considering a refinance but haven’t yet applied, a
private appraisal gives you a clear picture of where your home’s value likely stands before you
commit. It can help you determine whether the timing is right, flag issues worth addressing
beforehand, and give you confidence going into the process.

From the time an appraisal is ordered to the time the completed report is delivered, the typical
timeline is anywhere from five to ten business days depending on the complexity of the property,
appraiser availability, and current market demand.

The physical inspection itself usually takes between thirty minutes and two hours depending on
the size and condition of the home. After the inspection, the appraiser researches comparable
sales, analyzes market data, and writes the full report — a process that requires significantly
more time than the walkthrough itself. During busy real estate seasons, timelines can extend, so
it’s always wise to order early when working against a closing deadline.

QUESTIONS ON APPRAISALS

During the walkthrough, the appraiser will conduct a thorough visual inspection of the interior and exterior of the home. They are documenting the property’s overall condition, size, layout, features, and any improvements or deficiencies that could affect value.

Here’s what the appraiser is typically noting during the visit:

● Size and layout: square footage, number of bedrooms and bathrooms, room functionality

● Condition: overall maintenance, any visible damage or deferred repairs

● Features and finishes: flooring, countertops, cabinetry, fixtures, and upgrades

● Systems: heating, cooling, plumbing, and electrical in observable condition

● Exterior: roof condition, siding, windows, garage, and lot characteristics

The appraiser is not a home inspector and will not test systems or probe for hidden defects. They are forming a professional opinion based on what is visible and observable at the time of the inspection.

These two services are often confused, but they serve very different purposes. A home
appraisal is focused on determining the fair market value of a property. A home inspection is
focused on evaluating the condition of the home’s systems and structure to identify defects,
safety concerns, or items in need of repair.

An appraiser is a valuation professional — they are not qualified or licensed to perform
inspections. A home inspector is a condition expert — they are not determining value. Both are
valuable tools in a real estate transaction, and in most purchase transactions both will be
ordered. Think of the appraisal as answering “what is it worth?” and the inspection as answering
“what is its condition?”

The appraiser is forming an opinion based on what they observe, so presenting the home in its best light — while being honest about its condition — is always in your best interest.

Here are some practical steps to take before the appraiser arrives:

● Complete minor repairs: fix leaky faucets, patch holes in walls, replace burned-out bulbs

● Clean and declutter: a tidy home is easier to inspect and photographs better for the report

● Improve curb appeal: mow the lawn, trim hedges, and clear the entryway

● Compile a list of improvements: gather permits, receipts, or records of any upgrades you’ve made

● Ensure access: make sure the appraiser can access all rooms, the attic, basement, and garage

● Note any unique features: if your home has something special that might not be immediately obvious, it’s appropriate to mention it

You don’t need to stage the home like it’s for sale, but a well-maintained, accessible, and organized home signals pride of ownership — and that matters.

Appraisers are trained to evaluate a wide range of property characteristics that influence market value. While every property is unique, there are consistent factors that appraisers analyze in virtually every residential assignment.

● Location: neighborhood quality, proximity to amenities, school districts, and market demand in the area

● Size: gross living area, lot size, and how the home’s footprint compares to others nearby

● Condition: overall maintenance level, age of major systems, and visible wear or damage

● Features: bedroom and bathroom count, garage, basement, fireplace, deck, and other amenities

● Upgrades and updates: kitchen and bath renovations, new roof, HVAC, windows, and flooring

● Comparable sales: recent sales of similar homes in the area that help establish what the market will bear

The appraiser’s job is to weigh all of these factors together and arrive at a well-supported, data-driven opinion of value.

Yes, but perhaps not in the way most people expect. Curb appeal itself — things like
landscaping, exterior paint, and a well-maintained yard — doesn’t have a fixed dollar value that
appraisers assign. However, it contributes to the appraiser’s assessment of the home’s overall
condition, which absolutely impacts value.

A home with strong curb appeal signals to the appraiser that the property has been well cared
for, which often correlates with better interior condition as well. Conversely, a neglected exterior
can raise questions about deferred maintenance throughout the property. First impressions
matter in appraisals just as they do in real estate marketing — a clean, well-kept exterior sets a
positive tone for the entire inspection.

Generally yes — kitchens and bathrooms are among the most value-influential spaces in a
home, and meaningful updates in these areas are recognized by appraisers. However, the
degree of impact depends heavily on the quality of the work, the materials used, and whether
the updates are consistent with what buyers in your market expect and are willing to pay for.

A high-end kitchen renovation in a modest neighborhood may not return its full cost in appraised
value simply because the market in that area won’t support it. On the other hand, a
well-executed, mid-range kitchen update in a competitive market can meaningfully move the
needle. The key takeaway is that updates add value when they are quality work that aligns with
the expectations of local buyers.

Age alone doesn’t determine value — condition and updates do. An older home that has been
consistently maintained and thoughtfully updated can absolutely compete with newer
construction in the same market. What appraisers are really evaluating is the effective age of
the home, which reflects its actual condition rather than simply how many years it has been
standing.

A 1960s home with a new roof, updated mechanicals, renovated kitchen and baths, and fresh
finishes may have an effective age far younger than its actual age. Conversely, a newer home

that has been poorly maintained may be viewed less favorably. Age is a data point, not a
verdict.

Several factors can negatively impact your appraised value — some within your control, and some not. Being aware of both helps you set realistic expectations and make smart decisions before the appraisal takes place.

Within your control:

● Deferred maintenance and unaddressed observable repairs

● Dated kitchens and bathrooms behind comparable homes in the market

● Poor condition of flooring, fixtures, or major systems

Outside your control:

● Declining market conditions or falling comparable sales in your area

● Location factors such as proximity to busy roads, commercial properties, or flood zones

● Functional obsolescence such as an awkward floor plan that doesn’t align with current buyer preferences

Low appraisals are less common than people fear, but they do happen. Industry data suggests
that a small percentage of purchase appraisals come in below the contract price — estimates
typically range from five to ten percent depending on market conditions. In fast-moving markets
where prices are rising quickly, the gap between buyer offers and appraised values can widen
simply because comparable sales haven’t caught up to current demand.

When an appraisal does come in low, it doesn’t automatically derail the transaction. There are
several paths forward including negotiating the purchase price, the buyer making up the
difference in cash, or challenging the appraisal through a formal reconsideration of value
process.

Yes – and if you believe the appraisal contains errors or overlooked relevant information, it is worth pursuing. The formal process is called a Reconsideration of Value, or ROV, and it gives you the opportunity to present additional data or identify factual errors for the appraiser to review.

A strong ROV is specific and data-driven. What appraisers and lenders take seriously are documented concerns such as:

● Comparable sales that were not considered in the original report

● Factual errors such as incorrect square footage or missing rooms

● Improvements or updates that were not reflected in the appraisal

Always work through your lender when submitting an ROV, as direct contact with the appraiser may not be permitted. Evidence-based and respectful is always your strongest approach.